Sunday , 27 September 2020
Home > Articles > National Judicial Council queries Enugu Chief Judge on misconduct
Enugu State Chief Judge Innocent Umezulike (second left) shaking hands with Governor Ifeanyi Ugwuanyi

National Judicial Council queries Enugu Chief Judge on misconduct

The National Judicial Council (NJC), has moved to toughen its stand against erring judges in Nigeria and has, to this effect, issued a query to the Chief Judge of Enugu State, Justice Innocent Azubuike Umezulike over alleged misconduct.

The query was signed by the Chief Justice of Nigeria and the Chairman of the National Judicial Council, and reads like this:”I forward herewith a petition Ref. No MISC/23/2016 dated 19th February, 2016 against you by one Peter N. Eze on the above subject matter. The petition speaks for itself. I shall be glad to have your comments within two weeks from the date of your receipt of this letter, please.”

In the document, the petitioner alleged that Justice Umezulike refused to comply with an NJC directive instructing him to transfer some cases from his court to another judge after he was accused of bias in the handling of those cases, and continued to hear the cases. Part of the petition reads:”In view of the earlier directive by Your Lordship (the CJN) had given that 3 cases involving Diamond Bank Plc pending before Hon. Justice Umezulike be transferred out of his court, judicial propriety required that Hon. Justice Umezulike tread with caution in suits involving Diamond Bank Plc., and assign them to other courts for hearing”.

Earlier in February, this year, the Attorney-General of the Federation and Minister for Justice, Abubakar Malami, asked the NJC to investigate Justice Umezulike for alleged misconduct. The minister, in a letter with reference number HAGF/ENUGU/2000/1, and dated 4th February, 2016, also directed the Inspector-General of Police to investigate the conduct of Justice Umezulike and one Mr. Vincent Aneke, the Director of Litigation at the Enugu State High Court over an allegation that they both altered a court judgment and order in Suit No.: E/170/76, dated June 25, 1985. The letter, which was signed by the Special Assistant to the Minister, Mr. Okoi Obono-Obla, also directed the Chairman of the Independent Corrupt Practices and other Related Offences Commission (ICPC) to investigate Aneke for corruption and abuse of office.

The minister’s letter was sequel to a petition to him, dated November 25, 1985, by a lawyer, Mr. Peter Eze, complaining of forgery and corrupt practices against the Enugu Chief Judge and Director of Litigation, and read in part: “On June 25, 1985, Justice P.K. Nwokedi, the Chief Judge of Anambra State ( who later became a justice of the Supreme Court of Nigeria) delivered a judgment in Suit No:E/170/76; Nnaji & Ors vs V. Nwugwu & Ors. The judgment awarded the plaintiffs, the Umunneshi Family of Umunnaji Ngene, Amechi Uwani, title to a parcel of land known as and called Agbirigba Umu-Nensi”.

“Surprisingly, sometime in 2009, Aneke and the Chief Judge of Enugu State, Justice Umezulike, forged a judgment order in the said suit, in which Justice Umezulike and Aneke claimed that Justice Umezulike heard the said suit in 1985 and delivered judgment in the suit. No mention is made in the said judgment order, that the suit was heard by Hon. Justice P.K. Nwokedi. The said judgment order was also purportedly signed by Mr. Vin Aneke, Director, Litigation and Courts Division, High Court, Enugu State, on the same date”.

“It will interest you to know that Justice Umezulike was called to the Nigerian Bar in 1980 and was only elevated to the Bench in 1993 when he was appointed a judge of the High Court of Enugu State. At the time he was said to have signed the said judgment order in 2009, Justice Umezulike knew that he was not the judge who heard the case, and that he was not a High Court judge in 1985, and certainly was never a High Court judge in Anambra State”.

“Similarly, Aneke was only called to the Nigerian Bar in 2002 after reading evening law, and was not a lawyer in 1985. He was also not the Director, Litigation and Courts Division in the High Court of Anambra State in 1985”.
“The purpose of Justice Umezulike and Aneke forging and uttering the said judgment order, was for the judgment order to be used by the Plaintiffs in Suit No:E/170/76: Nnaji &Ors vs V. Nwugwu & Ors to levy execution pursuant to the judgment and hand over possession of the said Agbirigba Umu-Nensi land to the plaintiff”.

“Permit me to point out that both Justice Umezulike and Aneke, knew that under the Sheriffs and Civil Process Act and the judgment Enforcement Rules of Enugu State, the fraudulent and criminal enterprise they had embarked upon was illegal. Thus (1) at the time application was made to enforce the judgment on 5/2/2009, the original parties to the suit were dead and contrary to Order V Rule 2, the dead plaintiffs were not substituted”.

“(2) Order V Rule 8 requires that as between the original parties to the suit, process should issue within 6 years; (3) Six years had passed since the judgment was delivered and no leave of court was sought or obtained before the writ of possession was issued. I attach herewith and mark Annexure 3, the warrant for possession signed by Justice Umezulike dated 6/2/2009. There is no note on the process to show that leave was sought and obtained.

“(4) Both Justice Umezulike and Aneke knew that before the judgment could be enforced, the above steps were required to be taken, and they deliberately closed their eyes so as to aid the plaintiffs enforce a judgment which has lapsed”.

“The forged judgment order allegedly dated June 25th, 1985 was then used by Aneke to apply to the Commissioner of Police, Enugu State, for policemen to enforce the court order”.

“On March 27th, 2009, Aneke, using the Bailiffs of the High Court, Enugu and with the connivance of Justice Umezulike took forcible possession of the land in dispute in the said case. At the back of the warrant of possession, is endorsed the acknowledgment by the plaintiffs that the land was handed over to them”, the petition noted.

The way things are going, Justice Umezulike and Aneke may soon join the growing ranks of judges and notable legal practitioners who are presently under the microscope for one alleged malfeasance or the other.

Download PDF

Check Also

Reporters Without Borders: Nigeria is one of the most dangerous places in West Africa for journalists

21 April 2020 The 2020 edition of the World Press Freedom Index, which evaluates the situation …